Department of Computer Science, Faculty of Computer and Information Technology, University of Taif, Taif, Saudi Arabia
Corresponding author Email: Eman.firstname.lastname@example.org
Article Publishing History
Accepted After Revision: 29/12/2018
Ontology population is an instantiation of the ontology classes and subclasses. Ontology population is the main step in ontology construction. However, the manual population is a time-consuming task. Accordingly, automatic or semi-automatic methods to populate an ontology are required. This paper suggests an approach for the creation of an ontology and its population. The studied ontology is related to named entities in the holy Quran. The major contribution of this approach is to harness the benefits of learning methods, conjoined with statistical models to extract contexts (words surrounding a named entity) from Quran and Hadith and retain the weighty contexts for the recognition of supplementary named entities to populate the ontology.
Ontology; Holy Quran; Named Entity; Machine Learning
Elkhammash E, Abdessalem W. B. A Holy Quran Ontology Construction with Semi-Automatic Population. Biosc.Biotech.Res.Comm. VOL 12 NO1 (Spl Issue February) 2019.
Elkhammash E, Abdessalem W. B. A Holy Quran Ontology Construction with Semi-Automatic Population. Biosc.Biotech.Res.Comm. VOL 12 NO1 (Spl Issue February) 2019. Available from: https://bit.ly/2XpPlQY
The Holy Quran is a document having its proper and unique style. It is a base knowledge discussing practically all life fields. Ontology is a type of knowledge representation and it became a major device for numerous applications that are interested in the semantic content. A holy Quran ontology will offer a powerful representation of its knowledge. An ontology with named entities of the holy Quran will be useful for implementing many applications (information retrieval, information extraction). The population of this ontology is also a huge task.
This paper aims to create an ontology related to named entities in the Holy Quran (names of god, angels, prophets…) from the holy Quran and prophetic traditions (Hadith). Hadith is considered as a very important source of Islamic knowledge. In our work, we preferred to use Sahih Al-Bukhari  and Sahih Muslim  collections to extract instances of the concepts described by the ontology.
This work proposes, also, a new approach, which is Natural Language Processing (NLP)-independent process for a semi-automatic population of a Quran ontology from texts (Quran and Hadith). This approach applies learning techniques and statistical models to acquire and classify ontology instances.
The article is organized into five sections as follows. Section 2 summarizes related work. Section 3 presents the proposed approach related to holy Quran ontology construction and population. Section 4 describes the implementation experiments. Finally, section 5 concludes the work.
Several studies have been undertaken on the topic of Quran ontology. In this section, we introduce some researches that describe Quranic ontology.Quran corpus ontology that describes around 300 concepts in Quran and 350 relations between them. It is available at (http://corpus.quran.com/ontology). Quran corpus focuses only on concepts mentioned in Quran and provides features such as Arabic grammar, syntax, and morphology for each word in the Holy Quran .
Another work in  developed an OWL ontological model for Quranic concepts described in the Quran. SPARQL queries are then used to retrieve the knowledge from the Ontology where single queries can extract similar concepts of the holy Quran which are spread out over different chapters and verses.There are numerous researches that developed a particular chapter in Quran or focused on particular subjects such as  that described domain ontology of living creatures and introduced semantic search of the living creatures mentioned in the Holy Quran including animals and birds. Also  proposed an ontology for “Salat (prayers)” based on translated texts of the Quran.
All the above mentioned works either focused on particular subjects in Quran or built ontology based on several concepts existing in Quran, but did not use approaches or methods to ensure that the conceptualisation is comprehensive.
The ontology developed in this paper augments concepts from Quran and Hadith. Moreover, we provide in this paper a new approach to further extend the developed ontology using learning methods.
A large number of methods exist for ontological engineering, describing the steps for the construction of an ontology. The building of the Holy Quran ontology was directed by the University of Stanford . It comprises the following steps:
- Step1: Definition of the ontology domain and scope.
- Step2: Exploration of the possibility to reuse existing ontologies.
- Step 3: Identification of the ontology terms.
- Step 4: Definition of the ontology hierarchy of classes.
- Step 5: Definition of the classes’ attributes.
- Step 6: Definition of the attributes’ values.
- Step 7: Population of the ontology.
The steps we follow to develop the proposed holy Quran ontology baptized: NEQ-Ontology are as follows.
Step 1: Definition of the ontology domain and scope: this step allows determining the ontology domain by answering (A) a set of basic questions (Q), such as:
Q: What is the domain that the ontology will cover?
A: Named entities in the Holy Quran and Hadith.
Q: For what we will use the ontology?
A: For many applications dealing with the holy Quran, such as information retrieval, information extraction, text mining…
Q: What types of questions will the ontology answers to?
A: The names of God, angels, devil, hell, paradise…
Q: Who will use and maintain the ontology?
A: Researchers interested in the study of the holy Quran and Hadith
Step 2: Exploration the possibility to reuse existing ontologies
The ontology “corpus. Quran”  is showing a classification of 300 concepts that appear in the Quran. This ontology is used to retrieve semantically relevant verses. However, this ontology does not hold all the class’ instances. For example, the god names are missing, only the name “Allah” exists. Also, some angels ‘names are indicated in the authentic texts: Sahih ElBukhari and Sahih Muslim (i.e. Israfeel, Monkir, Nakeer) do not exist in this ontology.
We will reuse some of the concepts that appear in this ontology , rather than develop a new one from scratch. However, we will make a new taxonomy and populate this ontology based on the Holy Quran and Hadith of Sahih ElBukhari and Sahih Muslim.
Step 3: Identification of the ontology terms
A complete list of the terms (in a non-structured form) related to the ontology domain is defined. For example God, angels, prophet, religion, language, Holy Book, food, disease, animal, body organ, mosque, vegetable, tree, Planets, events, month, day, location, mountain, color, etc.
Step 4: Definition of the ontology hierarchy of classes
In this step, based on the terms defined in the previous step, classes are defined in a hierarchical taxonomy.
Step 5: Definition of the classes’ attributes
The properties are attached to classes or subclasses taking into account the inheritance between classes and subclasses.
Step 6: Definition of the attributes’ values
The value types of the attributes are assigned to attributes. In addition, the multiplicity (the number of values for attributes) is determined, and the relations between classes.
Step 7: Population of the ontology
In order to create the classes’ instances of the ontology, we used a semi-automatic method. The process for the semi-automatic ontology population is proposed in the following algorithm:
- List-Occ fFind-occ (Instances, Quran, Sahih El Bukhari, Sahih Muslim)
- Cont fFind-Context (Instances, Quran, Sahih El Bukhari, Sahih Muslim)
- RankC fRank-Context (Cont, Quran, Sahih El Bukhari, Sahih Muslim, Instances)
- Instances fFind-Exp (Cont, Quran, Sahih El Bukhari, Sahih Muslim)
- Instances-Validation (instances)
- Return to step 2.
Our approach for populating the Holy Quran ontology with named entities performs as follows: (1) we introduce for each concept a small set of confident and well-known instances as examples of named entities (i.e. Jebreel, Mikaeel). Then, (2) we search all occurrences of those instances on the Holy Quran and Hadiths. For these occurrences, (3) we identify words surrounding them. We call context of a named entities, the set of n words that precede and follow the named entity. (4) We calculate the ranking of contexts to assure the quality of these contexts. The aim of this step is to identify the most pertinent contexts that appear in the texts. The ranking function is computed as follows:
Where, (cfi) is the context frequency, (icfi) is the inverse context frequency, (efi) is the example frequency, and (iefi) the example inverse frequency. These frequencies are computed based on the formula: Term Frequency-Inverse Document Frequency (tf–idf) . (5) Search segments matching the retained contexts. These segments are considered as newly named entity instances. (6) The found named entity instances are validated by an expert in Islamic knowledge and the initial set of instances is updated and extended by larger examples: the validated instances. (7) Perform a new iteration. In each iteration, the system learns, generates news contexts, and therefore new instances.
|Figure 1: Shows an UML class diagram designing QNE-Ontology|
The Holy Quran ontology (NEQ-Ontology) is implemented using the ontology editor Protégé 2000 . The ontology consists of 15 super classes (Figure 2):
|Figure 2: Example The NEQ-Ontology (root)|
Individuals are used to represent the objects (instances) of the classes. For instance, Al_Quran, Bible, Torah are represented as individuals in the Class Book. Mohammed, Musa, Essa are individuals in the subclass Prophet under Person class. Al-Qaswa is an individual of Cow subclass under Animal class. Figure 3 shows some individuals of NEQ ontology.
|Figure 3: Sample of the individuals|
Properties are binary relations on individuals. Figure 4 shows sample of object properties of NEQ ontology.
|Figure 4: Sample of the object properties of NEQ_Ontology|
For instance, in the context of the story mentioned in the holy Quran that describes the Almighty order to Bani Israel to slaughter a cow. We have Miraculous Cow, which is an individual in the COW subclass under the Animal class, and it is linked to Yellow individual via the object property has Color to describe the color of the Miraculous Cow. The individual Musa under Prophet class is linked to the individual Bani Israel of Tribal class via the property SenderTo. Moreover, the individual Musa is linked to the individual Miraculous Cow via the property has Mircaulous.
A class can extend another class, for instance, Animal class in Figure 5 can be divided into a number of subclasses such as, Reptile, Mammal, Arthpod… subclasses and Mammal class can further be extended into a number of subclasses such as Horse, Ewe, etc.
|Figure 5: Sample of class hierarchy of Animal|
According to Sahih Muslim Hunting animal are five which is Crow or Mad Dog or Kite or Mouse or Scorpion. We use class equivalent, which is a built-in property that links a class description to another class description to define Hunting animal as shown in Figure 6.
|Figure 6: Class equivallent to specify Hunting Animal|
The OWL formalism of corresponds to the definition of HuntingAnimal can be shown in Figure 7.
|Figure 7: OWL for Class equivallent of Figure 4|
Protégé offers a number of visualization tools that facilitate visualization of the ontology structure. Figure 8 depicts a view of Camel class, which is a subclass of Animal and has an individual call Al_Qaswa.
|Figure 8: Visulazation of AlQaswa instance|
We used OntoGraf tool to visualize the ontology. OntoGraf is a visualization tool in Protégé which provides many features to visualize the structure of the whole ontology or part of it. It also supports various layouts to organize the structure of the ontology and view different relationships. For instance, the tooltip in Figure 9 showed extensive details about the properties of individual Al_Qaswa such as the source that mentioned Al-Qaswa, Al_Qaswa meaning,…etc.
|Figure 9: Tooltip shows detaials of AlQaswa|
This paper aimed to construct an ontology (NEQ-ontology) related to named entities in the holy Quran. The referred named entities are not exhaustive in the holy Quran. For this reason, we have used prophetic traditions (Hadith) to populate the ontology and extract additional named entities. Hadith is considered as a very important source of Islamic knowledge. In our work, we have used the Sahih Al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim collections.
In future work, we want to investigate methods to (semi)-automatically find not only instances of classes, but also new classes of the ontology.This work can be extended to other Hadiths (al-Tirmidhi, Ibn Maja…) and Fiqh (Temporal interpretation of Sharia rules (Islamic law). In addition, implementation of complete application covering the entire proposed ontology needs to be accomplished.
This work was supported by Taif University. The college of Computer science and Information Technologies.
- A. B. M. S. Sadi et al. Applying ontological modeling on quranic “nature” domain,” 2016 7th International Conference on Information and Communication Systems (ICICS), Irbid, 2016, pp. 151-155. doi: 10.1109/ IACS.2016.7476102
- K. Dukes & E. Atwell, E. LAMP: A Multimodal Web Platform for Collaborative Linguistic Analysis., in Nicoletta Calzolari; Khalid Choukri; Thierry Declerck; Mehmet Ugur Dogan; Bente Maegaard; Joseph Mariani; Jan Odijk & Stelios Piperidis, ed., ‘LREC’ , European Language Resources Association (ELRA),2012 , pp. 3268-3275 .
- H. Khan, S. Saqlain, M. Shoaib, and M. Sher, “Ontology Based Semantic Search in Holy Quran,” International Journal of Future Computer and Communication vol. 2, no. 6, pp. 570-575, 2013.
- M. Bin Ismail Abu Abdullah Bukhari Aljafee. “Sahih Bukhari”. Dar tuq alnnaja. Edition: I, 1422.
- M. Ibn Al-Hajjaj. “Sahih Muslim”. http://al-hakawati.net/arabic/Civilizations/80.pdf. Viewed marc. 2017.
- N. F. Noy, and Mcguinness D.L. “ Ontology development 101: A guide to creating your first ontology”. University of Stanford, Stanford. 2001.
- Corpus quran. http://corpus.quran.com/ontology.jsp. Viewed march 2017.
- G. Salton, A. Wong, and C. Yang. “A Vector Space Model for Information Retrieval”, Journal of the American Society for Information Science, vol. 8, no. 11, pp. 613-620, 1975.
- Protege. http://protege.stanford.edu/Viewed march 2017.
- S. Saad, N. Salim and S. Zainuddin, “An early stage of knowledge acquisition based on Quranic text,” 2011 International Conference on Semantic Technology and Information Retrieval, Putrajaya, 2011, pp. 130-136.doi:10.1109/STAIR.2011.5995777