Biosci. Biotech. Res. Comm. 6(2):
Management strategies for treatment of cardiovascular diseases in India: A review
Shaima S Ali* and PK Mishra
Department of Management, CRIM, Barkatullah University Bhopal 462026, India
India’s spending on health is poorly dismal, being less than 0.7% of its Gross Domestic Product (GDP), against an average of 0.9% of the low income countries. As a result, of this poor funding by the government on one of the most important sectors, there has been a sudden rise in private hospitals and their successful blooming. Hospitals in major cities in India in many cases are run by business houses, using corporate business strategies and high tech specializations. Thus, the marginal presence of the government share in health care leaves the door further wide open for alternative private health care suppliers. Hence the private sector is playing a very important role in India’s health delivery system and has a wide network of facilities that cater to health require- ments of both the urban and the rural populations. However, the major drawback is the high rising costs of treatment of certain upcoming disorders like that of cardiovascular disease, which has recently become number one non communicable disease. The age of technology has made life easier and made people more prone to heart diseases. These diseases are a global health problem with no geographic, gender, or
KEY WORDS: HEALTH CARE, MANAGEMENT, CARDIOVASCULAR, DISEASES, INSURANCE
Health care system in India during the last couple of decades has made a commendable progress despite being maimed with a serious setback in its early development, because of severe unavoidable circumstances. For example, the memories of the Bengal famine of 1943, which killed
*Corresponding Author Received 10th October, 2013
Accepted after revision 20th December, 2013 BBRC Print ISSN:
©A Society of Science and Nature Publication, 2013. All rights reserved.
Online Contents Available at: http//www.bbrc.in/
the country’s partition and independence thereof. However, much progress has been recorded since then. Life expectancy is greater than 63 years, and the India of 2014 is a thriving democracy with a diversified production base, a large scientific community, and an impressive information technology sec- tor. Since then, in India, health has assumed as a gigantically growing industry, and the potential is tremendous, as India’s spending on health is poorly dismal, being less than 0.7% of its Gross Domestic Product (GDP), against an average of 0.9% of the low income countries.
As a result, there has been a sudden rise in private hospi- tals and their successful blooming. Hospitals in major cities in India in many cases are run by business houses, using corpo- rate business strategies and high tech specializations, which create demand as well as attract high profile patients as the facilities in some of these hospitals are world class (Wilson 2009 and Health Information, 2010).
During the same period however, India’s record in expand- ing social opportunities has been uneven. The health and nutritional status of children and women remains poor, and India is routinely ranked among countries performing weakly on overall health performance (WHO, 2000 and WHO, 2008). But there is good reason for hope. The country has withstood the recent global economic crisis and quickly returned to eco- nomic growth. On the other hand, the marginal presence of the government share in health care leaves the door further wide open for alternative suppliers. The private sector plays a very important role in India’s health delivery system and has a wide network of facilities that cater to health requirements of both the urban and the rural populations.
With regard to India’s health care system, it is still pathetic. India has one of the most fragmented and commercialized health care systems in the world, where world class care is greatly outweighed by unregulated
One of the serious problems which has been staring Indian population is the recent emergence of cardiovascular diseases. A century earlier very few people used to die of heart diseases. In due course of time, they have become the number one glo- bal killer. The age of technology has made life easier and made people more prone to heart diseases. The combination of a sed- entary lifestyle and a rich diet has led to an increase in clogged blood vessels, heart attacks, and strokes. These diseases are a global health problem with no geographic, gender, or socio- economic boundaries. In the last couple of decades the dis- ease burden across the world has shifted from communicable diseases to
Cardiovascular diseases (CVDs) were once thought to be impacting the rich and affluent, but it is now well established that they afflict the poor as well. While changing lifestyles, unhealthy eating habits and declining physical activity are the key reasons for high incidence rates in the rich population, the issues of access and affordability account for higher mortal- ity amongst the urban poor and rural population. During this period and the coming of 2030, the global population is pro- jected to grow by from 7 billion to 8.5 billion people. The crude
Ali and Mishra
death rate is expected to remain more or less stable at around
8.4deaths per thousand. However, a major shift is currently underway in the overall disease burden in the world. In 2008, five out of the top ten causes for mortality worldwide, other than injuries, were
MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES FOR TREATMENT OF CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASES:
Despite the tremendous advances in cardiac care made recently, including drugs, devices, and diagnostic innovations; many patients still continue to die from heart diseases or live with significant morbidity either due to paucity of funds or ill- treatment, again due to mismanagement of economy. One of the dire needs is not only making radical economically viable improvements in existing heart remedies and surgical methods but also to extend preventive strategies such as improved life style, nutritious and healthy food, corporate health protection initiatives, health wellness programmes, promotion of medita- tion and Yoga to full effect to combat heart diseases (Delloitte ASSO HAM Report, 2011).
ecently, Preker et al., (2013) have described in detail theo- retical and practical aspects of healthcare such as financing, reforms, insurance and their limitations in several countries like US, China, Turkey, Thailand, South Africa etc along with India. The detailed World Bank report, covering several coun- tries along with India has suggested for strong public policies along with Government involvement for making an efficient, secure and equitable system of healthcare financing.
According to this latest report of E Library of the World ank, edited by Preker et al., (2013) health insurance, which has been a saviour world wide, is quite limited in India, all organized health financing arrangements cover around 110 million (workers, 21 million of them covered under Private Voluntary Health Insurance (PVHI). This is expected to grow in coming years reflecting a large untapped market as well as growth in income as a result of faster GDP around
total estimate or even higher than that.
Recent data of World Bank (2010) show that in India, 61% of private spending is on outpatient care, 57% of outpa- tient spending is on acute infections diseases, 85% of inpatient spending is in five areas
Ali and Mishra
and gynecology 17 %. According to the World Bank almost four fifth of health care spending in India today is met through out of pocket spending which is highly regressive. Organ- ized financing is barely developed. Hospitalization cost place a huge burden on Indian families, causing many to fall into poverty. Compared with income overall spending is high for a poor country like India but outcomes are below average, the need and the demand for healthcare financing reforms in India are urgent and strong .
These diseases impact not only the well being, but can also hold back the economic growth of the country due to increased healthcare expenditure and diminished productivity. India is projected to lose approximately USD 236 billion between
Though Indian hospitals conduct over ninety thousand heart surgeries a year, this is a small fraction of the 2.5 million required. While there is increasing availability and focus on curative care in urban areas, this alone cannot solve the prob- lem of CVDs. There is a need to focus on prevention and early diagnosis. CVDs comprise a major portion of
The Indian healthcare sector has seen improvements over the past couple of decades, but there is still a long way to go before we meet international standards. The improve- ments have not been uniform inequities based on gender, rural vs. urban and even social status still remains.While the government assures healthcare to all its citizens, 80% of all
India has seen a rapid transition in its disease burden (number of cases/ lakh) over the past couple of decades. The load of communicable and
Cardiovascular diseases are the largest cause of mortal- ity, accounting for around half of all deaths resulting from NCDs. Overall, CVDs accounted for around
9.2% annually, and accounting for the second largest number of NCD patients after mental illnesses. A more worrying fact is that the incidences of CVDs have gone up significantly for people between the ages 25 and 55 to 24.8%, which means we are losing more productive people to these diseases.
The interdependence between health and economic well- being is well established and there is a huge impact of car- diovascular diseases on economic growth and development. Between 2005 and 2015, India is projected to cumulatively lose USD 236.6 billion because of heart disease, stroke, and diabetes, shaving 1% off the GDP. This is based on the fact that in the year 2000, in the age group of 35 to 64, India lost
9.2million years of productive life, almost six times the figure for United States (Delloite ASSOCHAM Report 2011). Between 2011 and 2031, the number of people above 60 years of age is expected to more than double in India, (Economist IU, Nutri- tion Transition in India
According to Wahi (2011) in an excellent opinion on inte- grated health care system in India, it has been reported that despite increases in spending in recent years total yearly health spending in India is very low and India ranks 153 out of 193 countries with respect to total expenditure on health per capita. The government expenditure on health is only a quarter of total health spending with the bulk of the expendi- ture being private. The impact of this spending inequality has severe consequences in a country where above 50% of the population lives below the international poverty line of
1.25US dollar per day. According to the above author the stated goal of the NRHM launched in 2005 was to increase health expenditure from 0.9 % of GDP to 2.3% of GDP in the next 5 years, however despite increases in government health spending, this target has not been achieved so far (Wahi, 2011). Comparatively, in India public spending on health is lowest in the world, being between 0.94% to 1.4 % , in comparison, the figure stands at 14% for Maldives, 29% for Bhutan, 53% for Sri Lanka,31% in Thailand and 61% in China,(Kumar et al., 2012,TOI,2011).
Thus, Indians have to pay above 80% of their medical expenses from their pocket, called as Out of Pocket Spending, (OOPS). Paying off health care bills is crippling Indian house- holds. India’s per capita OOP to pay healthcare costs has gone up from Rs.42 83 in 2005 to Rs.68.63 in 2010. Experts recently have said that the main strategy to reduce out of pocket expenditure would be to step up the governments investment in public health domain - from the current 0.7 to 1.0 % of GDP to about 3% (Sinha, 2012, TOI March 16th 2012).
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
In conclusion, it is suggested that health insurance is the only economically viable option which can provide protection against risks or uncertain events and is based on the principle that what is highly unpredictable to an individual is predictable to a group of individuals. Health insurance protects against the cost of ill- ness, mobilizes funds and provision for health services, increases the efficiency of mobilization of funds and provision of health services, and achieves certain equity objectives.
There should be more awareness of health insurance schemes tailor made for Indian public in particular who can- not afford to bear the financial burden of high cost treatments of cardiovascular related disorders.
Though, health insurance in our country is in a nascent stage and contributes to a very small portion of the health expenditure, the government through its state run health schemes have played a significant role however they are not enough, as they are coupled with delays, corruption and mis- management. Because of this malady, the government has allowed the private insurance companies to offer health insur-
not been so successful, as it developed several problems , thus paving the way for creation of a third party involvement, in the form of the third party assurance the TPA. In order to remove such serious adversaries the emergence and future of third party assurance (TPA) becomes very important, which if properly managed can play a key role in the growth and development of a managed health care system. TPAs are sep- arate entities that coordinate between insurance companies, customers (patients) and health providers (hospitals), they arrange for cash less hospitalization and closely monitor the use of resources and services.
However it has been recently seen that the TPAs also do not have a very good working system with many of the insur- ance companies and hospitals and have been considered as hiccups between the health insurer, companies and the health service providers, leading to the failure of the health care sys- tem except for the few big insurance companies which have
we find alternative health financing mechanisms which are viable, cost effective and transparent, which can be a partner to the state and government run programs, health insurance is one such alternative, however in India health insurance market is very limited, covering about 10 % of the total population due to problems of huge magnitude.
The data of various studies points that there is a low pen- etration of the TPA through the health insurance. Thus there is a huge scope in terms of future expansion and business which can be tapped by health insurance companies in India through well organized and professional services of the TPA. It is strongly recommended that there should be an encouraging policy of the government through IRDA to use the services of the TPA in the future for the mutual benefit of the government i.e the public sector , the insurance companies , the hospitals,
Ali and Mishra
TPAs and finally the patients which have to be considered on top of the pyramid. Keeping in view this aspect it is recom- mended that the government along with the public and private health sector must evolve patient /customer beneficial health insurance programs for the middle and the old aged of all eco- nomic sectors involving the TPA, giving them more financial control so as to deliver better services and come up to the expectations of the real third party administrator.
Balrajan Y, S Selvaraj, SV Subramanian (2012) Health care and equity in India,TheLancet, Volume 377, Issue 9764 Pp
Delloitte ASSOCHAM Report (2011) Cardiovascular Diseases in India Challenges and Way Ahead www.deloitte.com.
Healthcare Information (2010) Health for all by 2015: HIFA 2015: (Accessed 16th August 2010).
International Heart Protection Summit (2011) Delloitte Assocham Heart Conference September 2011.
Kumar AKS, LC Chen, M. Chaudhary, S. Ganju, V. Mahajan, A. Sinha, A. Sen (2012) Financing health care for all: Challenges and Opportuni- ties, The Lancet, Volume 377, Issue 9766, Pp
Leeder S. et al., (2005).A race against time :The challenge of cardio vascular disease in developing countries Columbia University Colum- bia, USA.
Paul VK, Sachdev HS, Mavalankar D (2012) Reproductive Health and child health and nutrition in India: meeting the challenge. The Lancet, Volume 377.
Preker, Alexander S., A. Harding, EV. Velenyi, M Jakab, Caroline Ly and Yohana Dukham (2013) Scaling Up Affordable Health Insurance May 2013 Pages:
Sinha , K ( 2012 ) Times News Network. 16th March 2012, New Delhi: Paying off healthcare bills is crippling Indian households. India’s per capita
Times of India (TOI) (2011) : Health insurance and IRDA Regulations Nov 26, 2011
Wahi N. (2011) Integrated Health Care, The New Indian Express, Hyderabad, 29th December 2011.
WHO (2012) World Health Statistics 2012 contains WHO’s annual com- pilation of
World Bank Report (2010) World Bank Report on Developing Countries Health Aspects. The World Bank Washington, DC.
World Bank Report WBR (2012): Development and Climate Change.
Washington, DC: World Bank; 2012.
WHO (2002) World Health Organisation Report: Reducing risks, pro- moting healthy life, WHO, Geneva.
WHO (2008) The World Health Report 2008 Working Together for Health. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2008a.
PHP PDF ConvertedByBCLTechnologies